Best Italian in NOCO
RARE Italian (Fort Collins)
Elegant Italian steakhouse and restaurant in Old Town known for hand-made pastas, fresh seasonal dishes, house-made cheeses, and a strong wine list. Great choice for date nights and special dinners
2. PizzaVino (Windsor)
Family-owned Italian restaurant specializing in classic pizza, pasta, and wine, with a warm, welcoming vibe and thoughtful ingredients. Offers a broad menu including sandwiches and Italian classics. All ingredients imported from Italy!
3. Oregano’s (Fort Collins)
Well-loved local spot with solid Italian comfort food, pasta dishes, and pizza. Known for hearty portions and consistently good flavors in a casual setting.
4. Maida Trattoria (Fort Collins)
Classic trattoria with a broad Italian menu including pasta, risotto, and traditional entrees. A solid choice for relaxed Italian dining downtown.
5. Scalzotto Italian (Loveland)
Traditional Italian restaurant known for house-made pastas, ravioli, gnocchi, and classic northern Italian dishes. Often rated very highly by locals in the Loveland area.
6. Biaggi’s (Loveland)
Casual Italian restaurant at The Promenade Shops at Centerra serving a wide variety of house-made and imported pastas, pizzas, soups, salads, seafood, steaks, and desserts.
7. Pellegrini Cucina Italian (Greeley)
Often referred to as “The Best Restaurant in Greeley”, this restaurant serving southern Italian-inspired dishes in a warm, market-style setting is an awesome spot!
8. Anthony’s Pizza & Pasta (Fort Collins)
Anthony’s Pizza & Pasta in Fort Collins is a casual pizza and Italian spot known for New York-style pizza and classic pasta dishes, served in a relaxed, fast-casual setting. It’s popular for takeout, delivery, and easy dine-in meals.
9. Carrabba’s Italian Grill (Fort Collins)
Carrabba’s Italian Grill in Fort Collins is a casual Italian-American restaurant serving made-to-order pastas, wood-fire grilled dishes, and classic favorites in a relaxed, family-friendly setting.
